Link to paper

The full paper is available here.

You can also find the paper on PapersWithCode here.

Abstract

  • Presents Integrated Information Theory (IIT) 4.0
  • Aims to explain properties of experience in physical terms
  • Identifies essential properties of experience and expresses them mathematically
  • Can be applied to any system to determine if it is conscious
  • Makes testable predictions and allows inferences and extrapolations
  • Includes more accurate translation of axioms, a measure of intrinsic information, and an assessment of causal relations
  • Unfolds a system’s cause-effect power to explain the quality of experience

Paper Content

Introduction

  • Consciousness is subjective and IIT aims to explain it in physical terms
  • IIT starts with the existence of an experience, which is immediate and irrefutable
  • IIT has five axioms of phenomenal existence: intrincicality, information, integration, exclusion, and composition
  • Physical existence is assessed operationally from within consciousness
  • IIT proposes a fundamental explanatory identity: an experience is identical to the cause-effect structure unfolded from a maximal substrate
  • IIT has a mathematical framework to evaluate self-consistency and make predictions
  • IIT has been refined and extended over time
  • IIT has a book and wiki to explain motivation, axioms, postulates, and assumptions

Postulates of physical existence

  • Realism: Assumption of a world that persists independently of one’s experience
  • Physicalism: Something must have the power to take and make a difference in a reliable way to be granted physical existence
  • Operational Reductionism: Establishing what exists in physical terms by starting from the smallest units
  • Intrinsicality: Substrate of consciousness must have intrinsic cause-effect power
  • Information: Substrate of consciousness must have specific cause-effect power
  • Integration: Substrate of consciousness must have unitary cause-effect power
  • Exclusion: Substrate of consciousness must have definite cause-effect power
  • Composition: Substrate of consciousness must have structured cause-effect power

The explanatory identity between experiences and φ-structures

  • IIT proposes an explanatory identity that states that the physical properties of a complex can explain the properties of an experience.
  • The identity is not meant to be a correspondence between two separate things, but an explanation of the intrinsic feeling of an experience in terms of cause-effect power.

Box 1. methodological guidelines of iit

  • Explanations should be broad, unified, precise, coherent, consistent with overall understanding, and simpler than alternatives.

Overview of iit’s framework

  • IIT formalism identifies sets of units that fulfill properties of a substrate of consciousness
  • IIT determines a maximal cause-effect state based on intrinsic information of the system
  • IIT determines a maximal substrate based on integrated information of the maximal cause-effect state
  • IIT unfolds the cause-effect structure specified by a maximal substrate in its current state
  • IIT characterizes Φ-structures based on measures that satisfy the postulates uniquely

Substrates, transition probabilities, and cause-effect power

  • IIT takes physical existence as synonymous with having cause-effect power
  • A substrate is operationally defined by its potential interactions
  • A substrate is a stochastic system of interacting units with a finite state space
  • The transition probability function of a substrate is determined by a transition probability matrix
  • IIT does not require intrinsic physical properties or laws of nature
  • IIT is applied to simulated networks to illustrate cause-effect power

Implementing the postulates

  • Goal is to evaluate whether a hypothetical substrate satisfies postulates of IIT
  • Must verify if system has cause-effect power that is intrinsic, specific, integrated, definite, and structured
  • Existence requires capacity to take and make a difference
  • Intrinsicality requires system exerts cause-effect power within itself
  • Information postulate requires system’s cause-effect power be specific
  • Integration postulate requires system specify maximal cause-effect state in irreducible way
  • Exclusion postulate requires definite set of units, updates, and states
  • Composition postulate requires evaluating cause-effect structure of subsets and their causal relations
  • Formal account of IIT analysis includes determining cause-effect state, evaluating system integrated information, and searching for maxima of integrated information
  • Second part of formal account includes identifying causal distinctions and relations, yielding system’s cause-effect structure and structured information

Box 2. ontological principles of iit

  • To exist requires being able to take and make a difference
  • Eleatic principle states that entities are nothing else but power
  • Buddhist philosopher Dharmakīrti states that whatever has causal powers, that really exists
  • Principle of maximal existence states that what exists is what exists the most
  • Principle of minimal existence states that nothing exists more than the least it exists
  • Degree of irreducibility should be assessed over the partition across which it is least irreducible

Identifying substrates of consciousness through existence, intrinsicality, information, integration, and exclusion

  • Starting point is a substrate U in current state U = u with TPM T U
  • Consider any subset s ⊆ u as a possible complex
  • Refer to a set of units S ⊆ U as a candidate system
  • Units W = U \ S are fixed in their current state w ∈ Ω W
  • Obtain TPM T S of a candidate system S from its intrinsic transition probability function
  • Intrinsic information ii c/e is a measure of the intrinsic cause/effect power exerted by a system S
  • Integrated information ϕ s is a measure of the irreducibility of a cause-effect state
  • Systems for which integrated information is maximal are called maximal substrates

Existence, intrinsicality, and information: determining the maximal cause-effect state of a candidate system

  • A causal model is used to identify and quantify the cause-effect power of a system from its intrinsic perspective.
  • Intrinsic information is the product of selectivity and informativeness.
  • Intrinsic effect information is defined as the interventional conditional probability that the current state produces the effect state.
  • The postulates of existence, intrinsicality, information, integration, and exclusion are used to identify substrates of consciousness.
  • Existence requires that the substrate must have cause-effect power.
  • Intrinsicality requires that a candidate substrate has cause-effect power over itself.
  • Information requires that the candidate substrate selects a specific cause-effect state.
  • Integration requires that the substrate specifies its cause-effect state irreducibly.
  • Exclusion requires that the substrate of consciousness is definite.
  • Intrinsic information is quantified in units of intrinsic bits.
  • Intrinsic information captures the postulates of existence and intrinsicality.
  • The principle of maximal existence determines which cause/effect state the system should select.
  • Intrinsic information is formally equivalent to a measure of intrinsic difference.

Integration: determining the irreducibility of a candidate system

  • Identified maximal cause-effect state of a candidate system
  • Evaluated whether the system is irreducible
  • Defined a set of directional system partitions to divide the system into parts
  • Each part must contain at least one unit, no overlap between parts, and each unit must appear in exactly one part
  • Partition removes the causal connections of that part with the rest of the system
  • Defined a partitioned transition probability matrix
  • Integrated effect information measures how much the partition reduces the probability of the system
  • Integrated cause information is also defined
  • System integrated information quantifies the extent to which the system has cause-effect power over itself
  • System integrated information is a quantifier of irreducible existence

Exclusion: determining maximal substrates (complexes)

  • Multiple candidate systems with overlapping units may have positive values of ϕ s
  • Substrate of consciousness must be definite
  • Principle of maximal existence: system with most existence is chosen
  • Iterative search for system with maximum value of integrated information
  • Substrates with lower ϕ s are excluded from existence
  • Units must comply with postulates of IIT and be maximally irreducible